Showing posts with label signs of a fake psychic. Show all posts
Showing posts with label signs of a fake psychic. Show all posts

Thursday, November 19, 2026

How to Tell If a Medium Is Real: What Makes a Reading Evidential?

How to Tell If a Medium Is Real: What Makes a Reading Evidential?

Every medium eventually has to sit with a hard question: what actually separates a real, evidential detail from something vague enough to fit almost anyone? Dr. Gary Schwartz's laboratory research into mediumship, and the work that grew out of it, gives that question some real structure.

In Schwartz's early experiments at the University of Arizona, mediums were given nothing but a first name and asked to report impressions about a deceased person's appearance, personality, cause of death, and any messages coming through. A control group of ordinary people, given the same setup, averaged 36 percent accuracy simply guessing. The mediums in the study averaged 83 percent. That gap is the difference between vague, could-apply-to-anyone statements and genuinely specific, evidential detail.

A vague statement sounds like "I sense someone who loved you." An evidential one sounds like a specific cause of death, a distinctive personality trait, a detail about how someone spent their time that a stranger could not have guessed. This is exactly the distinction later researchers worked to isolate further. Dr. Julie Beischel, who continued this research through the Windbridge Institute, developed triple-blind protocols specifically to make sure a medium could not be picking up cues from a sitter's reactions, body language, or tone, removing every ordinary channel of information except whatever the medium claims to perceive directly.

I think about this distinction constantly in my own work. It would be easy to offer something comforting and general and let a grieving person fill in the rest themselves. Evidential mediumship asks for more than that. It asks for detail specific enough that it could not simply be assumed about anyone who has lost someone.

Schwartz's research has real critics, and I think that's worth saying plainly. Questions about sample size, about how much information a first name alone might carry, about whether enough studies were run for a few results to look impressive purely by chance, are all legitimate scientific concerns. But the underlying question his work raised, whether mediumship produces something measurably beyond guessing, has been tested seriously, repeatedly, under increasingly tight controls. That matters, regardless of where you land on it.

Browse more articles

Explore more articles about mediumship, signs from loved ones, grief, dreams, and the afterlife on the blog.

How to Tell If a Medium Is Real: What Makes a Reading Evidential?

How to Tell If a Medium Is Real: What Makes a Reading Evidential? Every medium eventually has to sit with a hard question: what actually sep...